Quantcast
 

You Asked: What Gives With Women's Bikes?

Wed, 10/08/2008 - 4:30am by FitSugar
1,509 Views - 17 comments

You're asking and I'm answering . . .

Dear Fit,
I'm in the market for a new bike, but while shopping I've noticed that there are bikes made for guys and then that company will make the same bike but designed for women. The colors are usually very feminine, which I hate. I'm wondering is it OK to go for the guy's model, or is there really a huge benefit to riding a women's specific bike?
—Tomboy Tara

This is a great question since so many of our readers are into cycling. To find out what I think read more.

Regardless of gender, you need to choose a bike that's right for your body type. Most women specific bikes are made to suit the average size woman who typically has a shorter torso than the average man, as well as shorter arms and legs. The benefit of choosing a bike designed for women is that these physical differences are taken into consideration in the construction of the geometry of the "cockpit" — the top tube, length of the handlebar stem, and the position of the seat. Here are some basic differences in women specific bikes: the frame is smaller, the distance between the seat and the handlebars is shorter, the distance from the seat to the peddles is also shorter, the brake levers are closer to account for a woman's smaller hands, and the bike is lighter weight so it's easier to carry. Sometimes the front bar is lower as well to protect your lady business in case you fall forward.

The bottom line is that women specific bikes aren't just made in girly colors, they're actually made to fit a female's body better than male specific bikes. Since fit is the most important thing, try to look beyond the color of the bicycle. If you tend to be on the shorter side, bikes designed for women will offer you more benefits in regards to fit and ease of riding. If you're taller, then the larger frame male bikes may be your best bet.

Fit's Tip: My advice is to test drive all brands and models, both male and female specific bikes. Some companies also make bikes in different sized frames such as extra small, so give those a spin too. If a rugged appearance is important to you, be sure to check out bikes made by Cannondale (like the one shown), Trek, and Giant since their women specific models don't necessarily look girlish.

Source

on Yahoo!

17 Comments Add a Comment

  • jesuisici's picture
    jesuisici
    2

    Terry bicycles make women's-specific frames that are generally not too girly looking. Women I know who ride them (most of whom had used men's frames previously) say the fit was life-changingly good.

    Girls bikes historically had a sloping top tube so we could ride in skirts without being indecent. That part's less important now; the shorter top tube width and adjusted saddle and handlebar positions are what you're really looking for.

    6 weeks 1 day ago Report Comment
  • esweet's picture
    esweet
    3

    My husband and I just bought Treks, but I bought the smallest guy model since I HATED the look of all of the girls bikes I saw (way too girly!) The problem is, I'm 5'1 and so I would probably be more comfortable on a frame specifically made for a woman. Oh well, I love my bike!

    6 weeks 1 day ago Report Comment
  • DigitalAngel's picture
    DigitalAngel
    4

    My Fuji mountain bike is the same color as the men's. They made it women's specific, but kept the same color scheme as the men's model.

    Try men's bikes though. I have long arms for my size and they fit me better. The only reason I bought the Fuji is because I was amazed to see a 17inch frame for women in my price range.

    6 weeks 1 day ago Report Comment
  • alliep627's picture
    alliep627
    5

    You should totally get whatever fits your body, height and frame the best. There are several components to getting the fit matched up right and you should find a person in a bike shop who really KNOWs how to do this for you or trust me you will pay for the mistake of getting the wrong bike. If you're just riding around town running errands it won't matter as much but if you're going to put any miles on this bike you don't just want to be comfortable - you NEED to be really as comfortable as possible to reduce stress and stress points on your joints and muscles. The women specific designs are frequently shorter from seat to grips. But if you're taller then there's absolutely nothing wrong with going for a guy's design. It's all in the measurements. I'm really short and the women specific design has saved me!

    6 weeks 1 day ago Report Comment
  • jesuisici's picture
    jesuisici
    6

    Word! Also, if you can find a bike shop with a female mechanic or owner (they do exist) go there. Women know about women's fit, and you're less likely to encounter weird sexist pricing issues (which also exist).

    6 weeks 1 day ago Report Comment
  • Linda McP's picture
    Linda McP
    7

    Thanks for the tips, Fit. I'm just starting to look seriously at buying a new bike, so these are most helpful.

    6 weeks 1 day ago Report Comment
  • fcseamstress's picture
    fcseamstress
    8

    I've got a great bike that fits me well, and it just so happened the gunmetal gray was on sale! But I know I got lucky. I can't see myself riding a pink or lavender bike either... The fit of your bike is definitely the most part, and I would recommend going into an actual bike shop where they will be able to help you select the best bike for you. If you really can't stomach the color, I'm sure there are a few bike shops that will paint it for you, you could try an auto body shop or the good old fashioned primer and spray paint route (but that involves taking the whole bike apart and putting it back together). Some brands do offer their bikes in multiple colors, but you will either need a shop to order from the manufacturer or to find a way to do it yourself.

    Happy biking!!

    6 weeks 1 day ago Report Comment
  • staticnoise's picture
    staticnoise
    9

    i was told that women's bikes are less stable than men's due to the lower bar. so i always prefer men's bikes, especially when it comes to trekking bikes, where stability has a great relevance.
    however, it's true that one should buy a bike, that fits the body, which can be easily find out be trying out different models in a local store - i would never buy a bike without testing it.

    6 weeks 1 day ago Report Comment
  • erikacklein's picture
    erikacklein
    10

    I ride a cannondale six thirteen - women's specific but not girly colors - dark blue, and okay, it has some stylized flowers but they match my aerobars....

    6 weeks 1 day ago Report Comment
  • rice a roni's picture
    rice a roni
    11

    I've got an incredible Trek Pilot 5.2 in Women's Specific Design. I tested several other brands, both men's and women's and loved this bike the best. The combination of pilot design with women's specific design makes for a great ride. It's a cool bright turquoise/blue color too, so just enough hint of girliness, but not over the top.

    6 weeks 1 day ago Report Comment
  • goatimpact's picture
    goatimpact
    12

    My Bianchi is not specifically for women but it ended up fitting me best. I test rode so many women's bikes that just weren't comfortable for me. I know there are benefits to buying a women's bike, as Fit said, but just make sure you try everything. And remember, your bike shop can change things out (saddle, etc.) if you need it.

    6 weeks 1 day ago Report Comment
  • mks0880's picture
    mks0880
    13

    At 5'3", I wasn't tall enough for a women's bike by Trek!! So I bought a little boys' Sad

    6 weeks 1 day ago Report Comment
  • kang's picture
    kang
    14

    Whatever works for you is the best bike. I'm 5'1" and find boys/mens bikes too long in the top tube. Bought a woman-specific designed Jamis Coda this spring and it's a fantastic fit. Not girly either. Nice blue and white.

    6 weeks 1 day ago Report Comment
  • Allytta's picture
    Allytta
    15

    i find it satisfying repainting my bike just the way i like it. but i'm a crazy designer...

    6 weeks 1 day ago Report Comment
  • Zero_Cool's picture
    Zero_Cool
    16

    If you're looking for a cheap awesome cruiser, my boyfriends brother just got one from xyzbikes.com and it's awesome! It was like $140 including shipping, there are hardly any stickers (I hate a bike plastered with the companies logo) and it comes in a large variety of colors! His is so cool, that I'm thinking about one for me as well!

    6 weeks 1 day ago Report Comment
  • sparklestar's picture
    sparklestar
    17

    I have a beachcruiser designed for a woman and I love it. A man's bike for a guy, I think you'd be quite uncomfortable riding one.

    5 weeks 6 days ago Report Comment

Leave a Comment

To post comments, please sign in or register.



Morsels of goodness, delivered daily.

Enter your email below:
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 











©1976-2008 Sugar Inc. | Privacy (updated July-4-2008) | Terms of Use | Copyright Policy | Advertise | Contact Us